The speeches by President Donald Trump and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth before a compelled in-person meeting with all our nation’s admirals and generals properly have been criticized on many grounds: improperly shifting the military mission to internal threats, explicitly declaring our cities as dangers to be met with military tactics, and rambling political diatribes irrelevant to our non-partisan military. One other item, however, deserves mention—the wholesale misuse of merit as the rationale for some of Trump’s most egregious policies.
continued...
Trump blurted, "Merit. Everything's based on merit...We're not going to have somebody taking your place for political reasons, because they are politically correct and you're not." Hegseth also bloviated buzzwords, criticizing anything associated with diversity and assailing what he claims was a “woke” culture.
Trump and Hegseth may seem like odd messengers. After all, Donald Trump is a son of privilege who evaded military service through dubious “bone spurs” claims. His choice of Hegseth elevated a Fox News weekend host over literally thousands of more qualified candidates. They could, of course, just be abusing the same stale white male privilege arguments from the 2024 campaign in a new venue, but let’s suggest to them a better way to look at the true state of meritocracy.
In September of last year, Daniel Laurison, Associate Professor of Sociology at Swarthmore College, and Sam Friedman, Professor of Sociology at the London School of Economics and Political Science, published important research on class and professional and managerial jobs. They used the U. S. Panel Study of Income Dynamics to analyze class position during childhood to adult occupations and earnings. They discovered that even when people overcome class barriers and become upwardly mobile, pay did not follow quickly or well. They wrote,
“[W]hen people who are from working-class backgrounds are upwardly mobile into high-status occupations, they earn almost $20,000 per year less, on average, than individuals who are themselves from privileged backgrounds.” Even when the researchers adjusted for education, race, and other earnings predictors, a substantial gap of around $11,700 a year lingered.
In other words, there is a “class ceiling” every bit as relevant as the glass ceiling for qualified women or the lingering effects of discrimination for black and brown job seekers. The audience for the Trump and Hegseth remarks seems a particularly mismatched one for their messages. For decades the military has served as a path to the middle class for young men and women from underprivileged and working poor backgrounds, people for whom the private sector opened only a few doors because so many spots (as well as promotion and pay raises) effectively are reserved for the sons and daughters of privilege.
If Trump and Hegseth really wanted to advance meritocracy, they’d expand upon the G.I. Bill of Rights. The original G. I. Bill moved an entire generation of high-achieving veterans into higher education, expanded the middle class and contributed to post-World-War-Two prosperity for decades. It was far from perfect, however, in its implementation, leaving behind many minority veterans who could have benefitted. Correct that now--as it is far better to thank and reward our military families than to call them names in frenzied nonsense chatter about warrior ethos.
Higher education itself is an area to show a commitment to meritocracy. Instead of cutting funds anywhere Trump allies find any hint of diversity, just add assurances that diversity and inclusion programs include commitments to first-generation college-attending students. Many universities already do that. Further, the next step would be to act against legacy admissions, opening more doors for meritorious students to advance.
We see no hint of these steps from Trump or Hegseth. Instead, we get minor variations on the old playbook of pitting poor whites against poor minorities (and men against women) so no one notices the grift of using government tax breaks and other policy changes to expand the power of corporations and billionaires.
|
|
Discussing:
- Pedestrians be careful, drivers (and pedestrians) not attentive (4 replies)
- All U.S. flights grounded until further notice (1 reply)
- Open AI escapes, hacks competitor (3 replies)
- Bravo to Michaela Barnett (3 replies)
- Federal Government sending marketing (campaign) messages? (1 reply)
- Knox SOUP Announces New Name, November 5 Community Dinner, and Call for Project Proposals (1 reply)
- Oconaluftee, Cherokee, Newfound Gap (1 reply)
- Check and Recheck your ballot when voting (5 replies)
- Bernie Sanders vs AI (1 reply)
- SoKno discombobulation continues (2 replies)
- Execution failed!!! (3 replies)
- GOP Senator "deserves the obloquy" (2 replies)
TN Progressive
- Blount County pausing on housing growth? (BlountViews)
- Tues., Oct. 20, 2026, Free Flu Shots at Blount County Health Dept. (BlountViews)
- View from the Overlook (Whitescreek Journal)
- Alcoa property taxes will probably not go up (BlountViews)
- Smith & Wesson not a good fit for Blount County (BlountViews)
- WATCH THIS SPACE. (Left Wing Cracker)
- America As It Is Right Now (RoaneViews)
- A friend sent this: From Captain McElwee's Tall Tales of Roane County (RoaneViews)
- The Meidas Touch (RoaneViews)
- Massive Security Breach Analysis (RoaneViews)
- (Whitescreek Journal)
- My choices in the August election (Left Wing Cracker)
TN Politics
- Alaska’s Peltola gives US Senate Dem majority additional cushion (TN Lookout)
- Jeffries chosen to lead US House Dems, poised to be first Black speaker (TN Lookout)
- Open Tennessee Senate seat draws competition in Memphis (TN Lookout)
- Commentary: John Cole’s Tennessee: Declaration of independents (TN Lookout)
- Pro-voucher group spent big on Blackburn, but not in the state House, throwing expansion into doubt (TN Lookout)
- Photo essay: The Equity Alliance, building Tennessee’s Black community for a decade (TN Lookout)
Knox TN Today
- Let’s Talk: Leaders — Recognizing those who lead, serve and give back (Knox TN Today)
- Crabtree Falls reopens: Morning light, fine friends and more healing from Helene (Knox TN Today)
- ArtBeat: Holiday magic takes the stage as Knoxville’s arts scene comes alive (Knox TN Today)
- Morning Chance (Knox TN Today)
- Game Ball: Tennessee welcomes LSU — can you predict the final score? (Knox TN Today)
- New Business Spotlight: 7 Brew brings coffee and community giving to Sevierville (Knox TN Today)
- Cecilee Rowlette-Strong builds a career connecting people and opportunities (Knox TN Today)
- Beyond the national headlines: A different real estate story in East Tennessee (Knox TN Today)
- Everyday Genius: Why you should put a dry towel in the dryer (Knox TN Today)
- Let’s Talk: Youth — Zoo opens new doors for Knox County families (Knox TN Today)
- Book Whisperer brings Nonfiction November (Knox TN Today)
- Young Reader’s Shelf: Stories that grow grateful hearts (Knox TN Today)
Local TV News
- Escaped Alabama fugitive arrested in Crossville (WATE)
- Delay in felony trial of Sevier County car restorer frustrates former customers (WATE)
- Former Heritage coach Joe Osovet denies interfering with concussion protocol (WATE)
- 'Real consequences': Knox County budget cuts raise concerns about special education (WATE)
- No charges to be filed after man died in Knoxville Police custody (WATE)
- Anderson County votes to keep Flock cameras after questions over contract renewal (WATE)
News Sentinel
State News
Wire Reports
- Asian Stocks Set to Fall Ahead of Anthropic Debut: Markets Wrap - Bloomberg.com (Business)
- L.A. County issues evacuation warnings as storm nears; snow, flooding expected - Los Angeles Times (US News)
- Elon Musk says record spending on US midterms was 'pretty foolish' - BBC (US News)
- Musk says Jensen Huang is irreplaceable, regrets midterm spending - CNBC (Business)
- More than a foot of overnight rain in South Florida causes widespread flooding - The Washington Post (US News)
- Elon Musk says he regrets midterm spending - The Washington Post (Business)
- Ericka Lomick’s Texas House Win Faces Challenge in State Supreme Court - The New York Times (US News)
- How Nvidia Chips Ended Up Within Reach of China’s Military - The New York Times (Business)
- Cornyn blocks Trump’s nomination to federal district court because he didn’t choose a Texan - The Hill (US News)
- Four Maryland high school students sue after AI mistakes Doritos bag for gun - The Guardian (US News)
- Cincinnati Zoo trying 'new approach' to help Fiona pass swallowed hat - WLWT (US News)
- Waymo pulls driverless taxis from freeways across the US after California ban - The Guardian (Business)
- Inside Nvidia's all-hands meeting, executives confront the elephant in the room: Jensen Huang - Business Insider (Business)
- Palo Alto raises annual forecast, signs $4.5 billion deal for Applied Compute - Reuters (Business)
- Duffy keeps blaming L3Harris after FAA ground stop, even as cause remains unknown - PBS (Business)
Local Media
Lost Medicaid Funding
Search and Archives
TN Progressive
Nearby:
- Blount Dems
- Herston TN Family Law
- Inside of Knoxville
- Instapundit
- Jack Lail
- Jim Stovall
- Knox Dems
- MoxCarm Blue Streak
- Outdoor Knoxville
- Pittman Properties
- Reality Me
- Stop Alcoa Parkway
Beyond:
- Nashville Scene
- Nashville Post
- Smart City Memphis
- TN Dems
- TN Journal
- TN Lookout
- Bob Stepno
- Facing South

+1. Thanks.
+1. Thanks.